Welcome to Carmelita's


Carm's Recipes for court reporters and everyone else that likes to eat!

(please send your favorite recipes - we will gladly test your recipes :)

Call 303.358.4969 to order Ramblings...off the record.

Carmelita's book is also available at Amazon

(The Myth of Continuity is just one of many true stories in Ramblings...off the record)

THE MYTH OF CONTINUITY

by Carmelita Lee, CSR

It was going to be one of those all day sessions at the office, even though it was a Sunday.  I had a deadline to meet, and brought along my daughter to help me; she would scope, I would proof.   To start the day off on the right foot, we decided to hit our favorite Beverly Hills coffee shop on Larchmont Avenue in LA, of 90210 fame.  My vehicle of choice (or necessity, rather) was a 1988 Chevy Silverado pickup truck, a leftover from my husband’s construction business.  Loved that beat up old truck.  350,000 miles, original engine.  The Chevy was adequate for my needs and served me well, but – well, she looked like a construction truck, and between me and my daughters’ driving and parking, and a long life hauling construction equipment, she was a bit banged up.
 
It was about 7:30 on an overcast Southern California morning.  The coffee shops along Larchmont are frequented by movie stars and the rich and famous, and over the years that we had been going to Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf, we had seen a good few stars ourselves.  We respected their privacy; they ignored us totally.  The novelty wears off when you share the same rarefied air, and the ambiance of Larchmont Avenue on a breezy Sunday morning is there for all to enjoy, all the more so when there are few up and about.
 
Parking spaces in Beverly Hills, I don’t know, maybe they’re extra wide because of the Rolls Royces that pull into them, but they’re huge.  You could probably pull in a fire engine or trash collection truck into the space I selected, and still have room left over.   At any rate, I pulled my trusty pickup into a space with plenty of room to spare, and as my daughter swung open her door to get out, the obviously very wealthy person opening the door of his brand new Mercedes S-Class turned to look at us, horrified.  He began to tear into my daughter unmercifully, so I stepped to the other side of my truck and said, “What’s going on here?”
 

We were nowhere near his car.  There wasn’t a hope in hell that we could have dinged his car, in fact I was able to stand between the two open doors to address him.   Yet he railed on and on at me and my daughter, not for dinging his car, but for having the nerve to park our “piece of sh*t Mexican lawn-mowing truck next to my brand new Mercedes.”  And it was brand new; the paper tags and sticker price were still taped to the inside rear window.
 
Two regulars from the coffee shop came out carrying their goods and stopped to watch our public humiliation.  Just as the Mercedes owner was getting revved up a notch, the funniest thing happened.  Three huge crows sitting on a light pole under which his car was parked decided to… simultaneously relieve themselves on his windshield.  Some of the thick white goo even splattered on his obviously expensive leisure wear.  The language that came from that refined “gentleman’s” mouth could have made a sailor blush, as me, my daughter and the two observers were wracked with laughter.  “See lady, there is a God!” one of them exclaimed.

 Frontier justice, don’t you just love it?

There’s a name for what happened to us that day; it’s called the “myth of continuity.”  My daughter and I didn’t deserve nor were we prepared to be dressed down for the simple act of parking our dinged-up vehicle next to a luxury car, and the self-important, highly agitated luxury car owner wasn’t expecting to be driving his prized possession to the local car wash that morning.  We all suffer from a delusion that tells us that today is going to be like yesterday, and tomorrow will be like today.  But ask any victim of any crime whether he planned to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, and listen to his response.  The incidents of “things gone wrong” can be anything from a minor and somewhat humorous aggravation to a major disruption in our lives, everything from your best dress being lost at the cleaners to a death in the family.  We have all had days where nothing can go right, when we’re all thumbs, when an already high-pressure day suddenly gets worse, and we need someone or something or God himself to rescue us. 
 
It is not hard to miss that our profession is going through a shakedown, locally and nationally.  State budgets get tighter and tighter, our country is supporting troops on several fronts and waging a real war on terrorism, which takes the focus of our leaders away from our everyday problems and concerns.  There seems to be belt-tightening in all facets of our market, including captioning.  One would think that captioning would be a safe haven for the highly skilled, but the reality is that even the sponsors who buy captioning services are pulling in their horns.  The nagging reality of it is facing us head-on, and our concerns are not trivial.

 Back a few years ago the federal courts were in danger of shutting down when the budget hadn’t been approved by Congress.  It’s a cyclical thing that comes up occasionally.   Budget approval was a frightening time for me because my husband is no longer able to work, and I’m the primary breadwinner.  Only essential transcripts were approved, and sometimes the beleaguered US Attorneys would come and beg for a transcript that they couldn’t approve for payment.  It was our choice, we could provide it or not; most of us did.  On the civil side, even the cash cows, the big corporations, weren’t ordering transcripts, or if they did, they weren’t the dailies one would have expected.  Myth of continuity.     
 
We went through a similar problem here in Ireland last year.  The market is extremely small, and reporting a trial is not always considered of paramount importance.  Up until the late 80's notes were taken by both attorneys and the court, and if an appeal were taken, the notes and the recollection of the parties formed the basis of the record for appeal if there was no transcript.  This is still the way it’s done in Israel.  Furthermore, except for criminal trials, cases are not reported at all unless the defendant hires us.  There are rare occasions that the plaintiff may hire us, and it’s not uncommon to have two reporters show up from two different firms to report a job.  In fact, I once had to do that, report a case while sitting directly opposite our competitor’s ace reporter.  Talk about pressure. 
 
Whatever it was that caused the work slowdown wreaked havoc among the reporters and the three small agencies that employ us.   The lack of work and the tremendous number of days off could have worked together to impoverish us.  The once busy courthouse was practically a tomb, and the amount of work that was available for the approximately 80 reporters in Ireland was nil.  My firm worked valiantly to provide an opportunity of work for its employees, having to parcel and rotate us through the few jobs that were available.   Jobs that would normally last the day would be split between two reporters.  It was a frightening time for most of us.  Some of the younger people were buying homes, some were starting their families, several of us are heads of households with non-working spouses.  I have to tell you, it was a tough, tough year.
 
One day last year, I suppose because I was bored and had nothing to do, I fidgeted around with my diary, deciding to memorialize how many times I had actually worked since January.  I made a graph and headed it Month, No. of Days Worked, and started paging back through the diary.  January, 9, I wrote.   February . . .  and as I started to count, the little voice inside instructed me to stop counting, and reminded me of a Bible story I knew well.  It was about King David, (2nd Samuel 24) who, like all wise kings, decided to count his fighting men.  But in his case, his strength wasn’t found in numbering his soldiers, and he was told it was a definite no-no to count them.   I shuddered when I remembered the story and the consequences, and decided maybe I shouldn’t count the days after all.  It was enough that I knew I wasn’t working the average 20 to 22 days per month, and there was one month when one couldn’t help but notice the five billable entries.   Myth of continuity. 
 
I was caught short, and decided to be proactive about my situation.  I decided to pray about work.   Faith has always played a large role in my life, and so I fell back into the familiar pattern for seeking solace in God.  I made a particular request; that each of my colleagues would have as much work as they needed, and that since I obviously couldn’t work more than was available, I prayed that each workday would count for the maximum amount of income.  I must say that we didn’t starve, didn’t go into overdrafts or fail to make payments.  In fact, we prospered.  The year turned around, new judges were appointed, and things leveled out for me and my colleagues.
 
Last month I met one of the most interesting deponents of my life; a working class Brit who, by the grace of God (as he said himself in deposition) had achieved status as an inventor of SWIFT.   SWIFT is the method used for international money transfers.  Even I have benefited from his invention more than once.  SWIFT made him a multimillionaire, although he didn’t look or act like one.   He lives in France (er, Fronce, he says), on 1200 acres that includes a lake, two rivers, a “wee stand of trees” . . . read forest there . . . outbuildings, stables, paddocks.  He was an expert witness for Bank of America, dealing in the area of fraud by bank wire.  As the day wore on, we learned that amid his successes, he had lost his first wife and child in an auto accident, and his second wife to a brain tumor.  His oldest daughter has had a debilitating disease, and he suffers from diabetes.  Despite all the above, he appeared to be a most centered and affable person, friendly and relaxed.
 
When the day was over I extended my hand to him, and, as an unexpected perk of my European job, he took both my hands in his and bent down to kiss both sides of my face.  “I managed to make you laugh at my silly jokes once or twice, luv,” he said, “and you were a pleasant part of my day.”  I was tickled by the kindness, and I added my own sympathy at his losses.  It’s not something we really get to do much in the States, talk to the deponents.  But it’s something I enjoy, and makes my mechanical role a bit more pleasant.   He smiled brightly at me, and he said, “Oh, not to worry.  I’m a happy person, and those terrible things shaped my character into who I am today.”
 
Myth of continuity.  What comprises the myth is that none of us knows exactly what lies ahead, even in the next five seconds, let alone tomorrow.  The only certainty we can count on is the uncertainty each day brings.  Life really is golden when there’s continuity.  When my kids were little they would ask me, “Mom, is the world ending?”   I am not an expert in these matters, so I took the safe road and told them that it could be, but we still have to pay the rent next month.  It’s a way of saying be prepared for eternity and for living each day.
 
Last year it looked like my reporting career was drying up and my reason to move to Ireland with it.  I decided to assess my skills and talents.  I needed to combat a growing sense of frustration and panic by taking control of my circumstances.  I had often been complimented on a certain cake recipe, so I took a chance and sent a cake to a local restaurant.  They loved the cake, and started ordering one, then two, then several a week.  Before long I was applying for a business license and seeking information into opening a bakery.  It wasn’t huge money, but I was able to successfully augment my income with cake and muffin baking from January to August of last year.  I was surprised by the response to my Cherry-Almond cake and Lemon Poppy seed cake, but it was bread-and-butter money for a while.  This is the unexpected, but in a good way.  It bolstered my confidence that we could make a living doing something even if the court reporting dried up completely.

As we watch our elected representatives fight ER, downsizing and layoffs in the public and private sectors, keep in mind that there really is an antidote for the myth of continuity: a contingency plan.
 
First, assess your own situation, your many talents and skills, and keep on working hard to stave away the wolf at the door.  Probably the single most important thing to do is not give in to depression; it won’t help, and will only make it harder for you to focus on what needs to done in a proactive way.  If you don’t have a marketable skill other than court reporting (and what a skill it is), use your time to attend classes, do volunteer work in your church or community, and develop your talents.  And always remember that you can use your machine shorthand skills in many ways other than just in depos and court.
 
Here in Ireland when the work-related drought hit us, one of my colleagues used his time to write the play he had always wanted to write, and got it produced; another worked as a part-time legal secretary.  I sewed christening gowns and made cakes for a couple of local restaurants.  One took classes to improve her computer skills. All of us used what skills and talents we had to occupy our time and bolster our coffers until the slow period ended.  I guess the way to deal with the curves life throws at us is to be flexible enough to roll with the punches and still come out smiling, like my deponent from France did.
 
Everything changes.  Governments topple, businesses fail, kids from ideal family backgrounds get on drugs, messed-up kids get scholarships and straighten out their lives.  Ordinary folks make extraordinary contributions.  Simple working people win the lotto.  And sometimes a busy court reporter gets to have a hearty laugh when a Hollywood bigshot’s car is covered in crow caca . . .

 Until next time,
 
Carmelita Lee,
Court reporter at large in Dublin, Ireland (Now in Israel :)

 
Yesterday I dared to struggle; today I dare to win. --- Bernadette Devlin

 

 

 

Website Designed, Maintained, and Hosted by

CourtReps
A CTICS-USA Company
Jeniffer Aloysius, Webmaster
Copyright 2005

The appearance of external hyperlinks in this home page does not constitute endorsement by Carmelita Lee, CTICS Inc., or CourtReps of the external website or the information, products, or services contained therein. Carmelita Lee, CTICS Inc., and CourtReps do not exercise any editorial control over the information you may find at the external location. The link is provided consistent with the stated purpose of Carmelita Lee, CTICS Inc., and CourtReps and is a public service to users of this website.